|
The two 8-cell Barak 1 modules |
|
Launch of Barak 1 SAM. Photo: IAI |
The anti-aircraft protection of the boats is provided by the Barak 1 short-range missile system that was developed by Israeli Air Industries (IAI) and Rafael, and has both anti-air and anti-surface capability. The supersonic (Mach 2) surface-to-air missile (SAM) Barak 1 missile is vertically launched from two 8-cell modules (in total 16 missiles) located at the aft section behind the naval gun. Boats in the class have been spotted in the past, perhaps just for trials, with four such modules therefore those boats could carry up to 32 (!) Barak 1 SAM which is not just impressive armament for boats in the category but also for larger warships such as corvettes or frigates such a large amount of SAM on board. The regular load is though two modules. The missile uses radar Command-to-Line-Of-Sight (CLOS) guidance, in which a ship-borne radar (the IAI/ELTA EL/M 2221 STGR of the boats) monitors the intercept and continuously guides the missiles to the target in a maximum range of approximately 11 km. The system carries a 22kg blast fragmentation warhead and achieves a very short response time (360 deg. coverage by vertical launch) as well as a short minimum range (hundreds of meters) against any kind of air targets including sea-skimming anti-ship missiles and low radar cross section threats with a high kill probability in a variety of challenging operational scenarios. Except Israel, this missile is in service with the navies of Chile, India and Singapore. Watch here a video from live fire exercises where Sa'ar 4.5 and Sa'ar 5 launch Barak 1.
|
Castaways rescued from a Sa'ar 4.5 boat sitting close to a Barak VLS |
|
Israeli Sa'ar 4.5 FACM and Italian Orizzonte class destroyer |
Except the armament and the electronic countermeasures suites which will be described later, each boat is protected by an impressive amount and variety of sophisticated decoys which are launched from three Rafel-built different types of decoy launchers! More analytically, the decoy launchers are the five 12-tube (one is twin 12-tube) 115mm launcher tubes for a variety of short and medium range decoys, the two 4-tube 90mm Long Range Chaff Rocket (LRCR) launchers and the massive trainable Deseaver decoy launcher that consists of twelve 6-tube (72 round launcher) 115mm launchers (140 decoys in total of eight different launchers!). For sure these boats are some of the best protected in the world. Rafael’s IDS (Integrated Decoy System) provides the automatic response, optimized for specific scenario conditions. The advanced decoys are programmed in real-time at launch for the best deployment range. System synergy is achieved by rotatable launchers that make optimal decoy placement possible. The IDS design concept enables quick reaction time by turning launchers towards the threat and rapidly launching the decoys. The IDS design concept also facilitates operational flexibility, which eliminates the need for ship maneuvers, effective ship defense that capitalizes on precise decoy location and optimized defense which uses sophisticated decoy patterns to defeat modern threats. The Integrated Decoy and Launch Controller launches expendable decoys to provide automatic, optimal responses to threats according to conditions of engagement. Available modes of operation include: automatic, semiautomatic, manual, emergency and maintenance. The man-machine interface consists of one or two operator control units, either a standard console in the CIC / on the bridge or a standalone display. The following descriptions of the decoys are retrieved from the company's brochures.
|
The Sa'ar 4.5 class FACM are protected by 140 decoys of 6 different types
that are launched from 3 different decoy launchers (2 in the photo)! |
|
Characteristics of Rafael's decoys that equip the Sa'ar 4.5 class |
The Long Range Chaff Rocket (LRCR) is a long range tactical confusion rocket used as a first line of defense against missile attack. This decoy is launched from the 90mm LRCR launchers. The rocket creates a ship-size decoy target at a range of 14 kilometers from the ship. The decoys create a large “protected zone” around the ship that deceives state-of-the-art search radars while the ship is still below radar horizon. the LRCR is deployed as a stand-alone high-performance decoy. LRCR decoys create optimal engagement conditions. They appear as legitimate, ship-size targets that mislead the enemy as to the ship’s actual location.
|
4-tube Long Range Chaff Rocket (LRCR) launcher |
The MRCR is a Medium-Range Chaff Rocket deployed at ranges up to 1,800 meters, before the missile has achieved radar lock-on on the ship. This decoy is launched from the 115mm launchers. MRCR decoys generate large chaff targets which are detected by enemy missile seekers as a legitimate target. During search, the enemy missile will detect the large chaff clouds, lock on the decoys and fly away from the targeted ship. Based on decades of operational experience, the MRCR is deployed as a free-flight, fin-stabilized, solid propellant rocket that creates a high-performance, lightweight chaff decoy. For operational flexibility and optimized defense, the decoy uses a programmable electronic timer set for the optimum dispersal range at the moment of launch. Before an enemy missile has detected your ship, the chaff target created by the MRCR is more "visible" and causes the incoming missile to lock on the false targets and fly away without attacking the ship. MRCR decoys are especially useful against missile salvos.
|
12-tube Medium-Range Chaff Rocket (MRCR) launcher at the front of the bridge.
Behind, there is a 4-tube Long Range Chaff Rocket (LRCR) launcher. |
The BT-4 short range chaff decoy provides seduction mode defense to protect the ship against active missiles that have achieved radar lock-on on the ship. BT-4 chaff decoys use rapid blooming chaff which, when deployed at optimum locations, create huge "targets" almost instantaneously that attract the missile seeker and deflect it away from the ship. The generated targets are huge; many thousands of square meters in size. BT-4 is deployed as a free-flight, fin-stabilized, solid propellant rocket which turns into a high-performance, lightweight decoy with a short reaction time and large RCS. For operational flexibility and optimized defense the decoy uses a programmable electronic timer set for the optimum dispersal range at the moment of launch. After an enemy missile has achieved radar lock-on, the chaff target created by the BT-4 causes the incoming missile to “switch lock” away from the ship to the decoys. The BT-4 decoys can defend against several simultaneous incoming missiles.
|
Elbit Deseaver 72-tube chaff decoy rocket trainable launcher |
Although most anti-ship missiles are radar-guided, a significant number of threats have infrared seekers or use an IR detector to discriminate against false chaff targets. An IR decoy is therefore a vital asset in the ship-defense arsenal. If an incoming missile has an infrared guidance system, the IR decoys confuse the missile's seeker, so that it misses its target. If the missile has RF guidance, with an IR seeker to detect false targets, the HEATRAP decoy provides heat sources to make the chaff targets generated by the RF decoys (BT-4 or MRCR) more realistic and effective against dual-seeker missiles. HEATRAP is launched as a free-flight, fin-stabilized solid-propellant rocket and evolves into a high performance IR decoy that operates either stand-alone against IR-guided threats or enhances chaff to generate realistic targets against dual-mode missiles. The payload consists of specially designed twin parachute flares, optimized for high IR radiation in the low and high infrared spectrum. The programmable electronic timer is set for optimum dispersal range at the moment of launch.
|
The Rafael 115mm decoy launchers that are
installed behind the superstructure |
|
Deseaver and OTO Melara gun in action |
|
SATCOM and modified OTO Melara 76mm gun |
|
WIZARD decoy launch |
Modern radar-guided missiles are a major threat to surface combatants. They are highly destructive and are capable of ignoring chaff decoys. Defeating these threats requires a quick response, adaptable decoy such as the WIZARD. The latest addition to Rafael's complete ship defense suite, the WIZARD distracts or seduces radar guided anti-ship missiles with chaff discrimination capabilities. The WIZARD is deployed as a free-flight, fin-stabilized, solid propellant rocket that opens out into a corner deflector. The return signal from a corner reflector has the same characteristics as a real target including scintillation and glint, since it is generated by a combination of reflecting surfaces, just as a real target. The WIZARD is compact compared to diffuse chaff clouds, which create a large opaque zone and create "self clutter". The WIZARD also prevents potentially dangerous situations in long encounters when lingering chaff clouds, not tracked by the ship’s systems, might serve as a “beacon” for a new threat. WIZARD is a high-performance, lightweight decoy. For operational flexibility and optimized defense the decoy uses a programmable electronic timer set for the optimum dispersal range at the moment of launch. The WIZARD is available in either single or twin corner deflector configurations.
|
Decoy launchers loaded with WIZARD decoys. Photo: Rafael |
|
Launch of a LESCUT anti-torpedo
decoy from a Singaporean FACM |
Modern acoustic torpedoes are a major threat to surface combatants. They have very advanced features and are highly destructive. Defeating these threats requires a quick response, intelligent and adaptable decoy such as the Rafael LESCUT. The LESCUT is a clever decoy that requires no pre-launch input/tests, which both shortens the response time and eliminates errors due to incorrect settings or operator mistakes. The LESCUT identifies the incoming threat and provides a tailored response, programmed to defeat all types of modern torpedo logic (i.e. range gates, Doppler shift, pulse discrimination, AGC/DVG, etc.). Whether the torpedo is active or passive, the LESCUT will be a legitimate target for it. Decoy operation starts automatically after launch, with the LESCUT submerging to its operating depth. The LESCUT analyzes the environment to determine whether the torpedo is active or passive and selects the appropriate deception signal for emission. Consequently, acoustic torpedoes will always prefer LESCUT as a legitimate target for homing in on; attacking it repeatedly and enabling the ship to evade the torpedo. LESCUT will operate for 10 minutes at a constant depth and then self-destructs and sinks.
|
The enclosed mast with MBATs around it, STGR at the left and ESM in the centre |
|
Sa'ar 4.5 with Gabriel II and two STGR fire control systems |
The guidance of Barak 1 SAM is performed by the IAI ELM-2221 Search, Track and Guidance/Gunnery Radar (STGR). Originally the boats in the class were carrying such systems but the one of the two systems was removed. The boats carry it at starboard or port-side and depending on the position of which the system is installed, they operate accordingly in formation. According to the company, whenever the hard kill of sea skimmers calls for uncompromising accuracy under adverse multipath, ECM and/or bad weather conditions, STGR is the ultimate Fire Control Radar to accomplish the task. The STGR is an extremely accurate, monopulse, dual-band (X & Ka) Pulse Doppler radar capable of tracking highly maneuverable targets after fast automatic acquisition, guiding missiles in single or salvo firing and directing guns against air and surface targets, with high anti-clutter and ECCM capabilities. ELTA (subsidiary of IAI) developed the STGR as part of the Barak 1 Point Defense Missile System for Israeli Navy missile boats. The typical performance of the system is missile acquisition at 15km, fighter aircraft acquisition at 30km, effective SAM missile guidance up to 10km, effective surface gunnery up to 20km (gun dependent) and effective air gunnery up to 4 Km (gun dependent).
|
Sa'ar 4.5 boat with STGR at the starboard |
|
Sa'ar 4.5 boat with STGR at the port side |
|
EL/M-2208 radar on the top of the mast |
|
Bow view of a boat of the class |
The air and surface search radar is an Israeli development of the Thales Neptune TH-D 1040 S-band multi-function radar, the Elbit (Elta) EL/M-2208 and certainly not the 2218 or the 2228 AMDR (that both equip the Sa'ar 5 instead) as it is reported on many sources. The system is capable of long-range air surveillance and surface (sea) search, and has the ability
to quickly detect anti-ship missile at the same time; in addition, can
support ship artillery fire control and anti-aircraft missiles. About five years ago, some online sources (source example) were claiming that the boats were about to receive the new EL/M 2258 Advanced Lightweight Phased Array Naval Radar (ALPHA). Just recently, in May 2017, the first of the boats in the class received the ALPHA system. Israeli Navy will proceed the installation of the radar on two more vessels this year.
|
The first boat with the new ALPHA radar during sea trials. Source: www.globes.co.il |
|
Elbit Multi-Sensor Integrated System (MSIS) and C-Pearl antenna above it |
Each boat is equipped with an Elbit (Elop subsidiary) Multi-Sensor Integrated System (MSIS) electro-optical observation, target
acquisition, weapon aiming, fire control and surveillance system. The system has been upgraded in the previous decade with a new third generation thermal imaging
Forward Looking InfraRed (FLIR) camera. The new FLIR enables MSIS operators to receive high
quality and long range video images under difficult weather conditions. System electronics were also
upgraded. The new generation MSIS is comprised of a daytime TV camera, in addition
to the third generation FLIR, and a rapid laser rangefinder. The system
features flexible compact sensor packaging, high performance
stabilization and high sensitivity and resolution.
|
Sa'ar 4.5 (front) and Sa'ar 5 (back) with a plethora of sensors. Photo: Kevin S. O'Brien |
And now the most feared part: the electronic countermeasures! Seriously, there is such a mess-up about the electronic equipment on the online sources that I almost did not take anything into account. The thing I did is to examine carefully Rafael's and Elbit's product brochures and also to look carefully high resolution photos from different angles in order to identify systems but also to understand (or guess sometimes) their use. One of the systems I could not identify though, is the following one in the photo, which equips both Sa'ar 4.5 and Sa'ar 5 classes. I might guess that its objective is electronic support measures (ESM) and it is housed in an enclosed mast to avoid the wind erosion and seawater as well as to reduce the whole ships radar cross section(RCS).
|
The panels of the ESM system immediately below the EL/M-2208 radar |
|
Digital SHARK ECM. Photo: Rafael |
|
SEWS ESM/ECM. Photo: Rafael |
The electronic countermeasure (ECM) system that is capable of jamming and deceiving threats simultaneously in different directions, is the Rafael Digital SHARK. The system is comprised of a modern digital receiver, sophisticated DRFM based technique generators and trackers and integrated Multi-Beam Array Transmitter (MBAT). Employing the MBAT for simultaneous coincidence jamming, high transmitting power and fast beam switching, Digital SHARK sets new standards in naval ECM. This system enables the ship’s EW suite to support appropriate defensive response against all types of airborne radars, surface radars and missile seekers. Two MBATs covering 360º in azimuth, enable immediate positioning of a transmitting beam with very high effective radiated power (ERP). The Shark easily interfaces with Rafael’s C-Pearl electronic support measures (ESM) and other on-board combat and data systems. The C-Pearl-DV ESM is integrated with Digital Shark ECM system for a complete EW Suite which I might guess here, it is called SEWS-DV, a suite designed for both ESM and ECM applications. It enables automatic detection, data measurement and identification of threats. A single small antenna array handles both instantaneous frequency measurement and instantaneous direction finding with common multiple channel digital receivers. This unprecedented combination yields very high probability of intercept at full dynamic range and frequency coverage with excellent frequency filtering. Using a high performance digital receiver, the ESM system is immune to interfering signals.
|
MBATs of SHARK and above them MBATs of NS-9003A ESM/NS-9005 ECM suite |
|
NATACS COMINT/DF system |
|
Sa'ar 4.5 with NATACS antenna |
The boats have been spotted in the past with an antenna atop of their mast similar to the one that equips Sa'ar 5 class corvettes and similar to other European frigates such as the Thales Altesse. This is a variant of Elbit's NATACS Communications Intelligence (COMINT) / Direction Finding (DF) systems. The NATACS System is capable of coping with advanced agile frequency communication radios. This fully integrated system - equipped with ultra-fast, Wide Band Receivers and Direction Finding (DF) Systems has outstanding scanning rates enabling the handling of extremely dense electromagnetic environments in the HF/VHF/UHF/HUHF frequency bands thanks to its Active or Passive receiving antennas connected through RF distribution units, characterized by frequency hopping, burst, and other agile transmissions. Among its main features is the Automatic Direction Finding and "FIX" signal classification and identification capability, focus on signals of interest by activating various filters and criteria (azimuth sector, signal type, etc.), monitor signals of interest (content & traffic), high-level analysis of suspected signals and signals of interest and high-capacity Digital Audio & IF Wideband Recording. In their regular load, the boats do not carry this antenna.
|
NATACS Communications Intelligence (COMINT) / Direction Finding (DF) system |
Another system, that quips the boats in the class, which though I am not 100% sure if truly this is it, it is a system by Elbit's (Elisra subsidiary) NS 9000 family of ESM and ECM system. Most reliable sources report the NS-9003A ESM and NS-9005 ECM suite where the ECM fully co-exists with the ESM and both maintain maximum operational functionality with no mutual interference. Utilizing sophisticated power management techniques, Elisra's solutions minimize or entirely eliminate the need for time sharing between the ESM's signal reception and the ECM's jamming and deception systems. The NS-9005PR noise and deception jammer uses two non-stabilized multibeam array transmitters (MBATs) based on the RAN-1010 MBAT, each covering 180°.
|
The Multi-Beam Array Transmitters (MBATs) of two different
ECM systems, a variant of the NS 9000 (top) and the SHARK |
|
INS Tarshish in 2009. Notice the different
arrangement of the MBATs. Photo: MathKnight |
|
INS Tarshish. Photo: MathKnight |
|
The interior of a Sa'ar 4.5's bridge |
Each boat carries one or two inflatable boats at the stern as well as one rigid-hulled inflatable boat (RHIB) that is launched and recovered by a crane located amidships. The boat's combat management system (CMS) is built by IAI and integrates all sensors, communications and weapons systems for synchronized performance of the combat system and ship. CMS provides a Common Tactical Picture and Threat Evaluation to support all levels of decision making processes and control resource allocation for engagements. The CMS assures effective utilization of the advantages of each system on the ship and optimal usage of their capabilities according to the situation. The basic traditional OODA (Observe, Orient, Decide, Act) loop model is applied to all major activities. The CMS interfaces with the major ship systems via a high performance LAN. Using fast Ethernet interfaces, the CMS provides a standard system interconnection scheme. Dedicated Bus Interface Units (BIU) support any other systems with special electrical interfaces. The combat room consists of Multi-Function Consoles (MFC).
saar 6 (light frigate ) will not replace the hetz class (missile boat) the saar 72 by israeli shipyards (800 ton ship) will replace the hetz when the budget is there
ReplyDeleteit is already in service with azerbaijan and cyprus as a guard ship
(no easa radar anti ship missiles or sams )
Thank you, I corrected the text.
DeleteHuge work!
ReplyDeleteMaybe, this news might be useful to you.
The Defence Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) has just made known:"a possible Foreign Military Sale to Israel for 13 76mm Naval Gun and Technical Support".
"The naval guns will be installed on Israeli Navy SA’AR 4.5 and SA’AR 6 Missile Patrol Boats."
The type of 76 mm choosen was not specified but, in my opinion, the most probable option is that it coul be the "Super Rapid" version.
Thank you! Yes, I mentioned that in my article "In August 2016, the Israeli Navy was in contract negotiations with the US Navy to purchase 76mm rapid-fire guns from Leonardo-Finmeccanica. Israeli Navy officers said the new guns would equip Israel’s surface fleet of Sa’ar-4.5 vessels, US-built Sa’ar-5 corvettes and the four new Sa’ar-6 corvettes which are under construction at the German shipyard ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems and of which the first is expected to enter service in 2019.". So if we talk about 13 systems, then we have 3 x Sa'ar 5, 6? (and not all 8) Sa'ar 4.5 and 4 x Sa'ar 6 that will receive the guns. But if they mention only Sa'ar 4.5 and Sa'ar 6, then one gun system will not be used.
DeleteThe press release coming from DSCA says that the possible sale of 13 guns will be for Sa'ar 4.5 (so, all 8 ships will be equipped with new guns), Sa'ar 6 (4 ships) and the last one will be located at an Israeli Naval Training Center, to be used for training maintenance personnel.
DeleteThere's no indication for Sa'ar 5.
That make sense then! Thank you for that information, I will include that in the article now that I have more details.
DeleteCheers,
Mitch
Dear D-Mitch,
Deleteit's a pleasure for me!
Great article, thanks for putting the time in to do the research.
DeleteThank you Nate, I am glad you enjoyed it!
DeleteIAI instals new radars ALPHA ELM-2258 radar system on the Saar 4.5: http://www.globes.co.il/en/article-iai-completes-installation-of-israel-navy-radar-1001188618
ReplyDeleteFinally a photo of it! They have announced that long time ago, I thought it will never take place the upgrade. Excellent news, thank you!
DeleteD.
Dear Mitch,
ReplyDeleteI have to say great work and analysis.
I hope to see soon a great analytical article like this one for the Saa'r 5 .
Thank you! Of course you will see, it is in my plans for sure.
DeleteRecent photos show Phalanx CIWS removed from Saar 4.5 and also Saar 5 vessels. Any theories on the reason?
ReplyDelete